College Admissions FAQ: Questions Families Ask

By PursivaUpdated October 202611 min read

Planning by year

When should you start preparing for college?

In 9th grade, and each year of high school has a different job. Ninth grade is for habits and exploration, 10th for building depth, 11th for the work colleges weigh most, and 12th for turning it all into applications.

What should a freshman do to prepare for college?

Get onto the right course track, build steady work habits, and find out what you like. Ninth grade does not call for test prep, a college list or a finished plan.

What should a sophomore do to prepare for college?

Keep grades steady or rising as courses get harder, go deeper in two or three activities, take a first practice SAT or ACT, and plan the summer early. Many summer programs close their applications in the winter.

Why is junior year so important?

Junior year produces the last full year of grades colleges see before they decide. It is also when most students take the SAT or ACT, get to know the teachers who will write their recommendations, build a college list and start thinking about essays.

What should seniors do, and when are applications due?

Senior year is for finishing the college list, writing the essays, arranging recommendations, filing financial aid forms and meeting each deadline, while keeping grades up. The Common App opens on August 1, early deadlines often fall on November 1 or 15, and regular deadlines often fall in early January.

Standing out

What is a college application theme?

A theme is the one idea about a student that every part of the application supports. It turns a record of grades and activities into a person an admissions reader can picture and remember.

How do I find my college application theme?

Look back at what you already do and notice what repeats. You do not pick a theme from a list, and you do not need a new activity to have one. Pursiva proposes possible themes from the student's own activities and shows where the evidence is strong and where it is thin.

What does a good application theme look like?

A good theme is one sentence that says what a student keeps doing and who it is for. Most strong themes come from ordinary activities, including jobs and family responsibilities, not national awards.

What is the difference between a spike, a hook and a theme?

A spike is exceptional achievement in one area. A hook is a category of applicant a college gives extra weight to for its own reasons, such as recruited athletes. A theme is the idea that ties the whole application together, and it is the only one of the three every student can have.

Grades and classes

How important is GPA for college admissions?

Grades are the most important single factor at most colleges: in a NACAC survey, 77% of colleges rated grades in college-prep courses as considerably important. But colleges read the courses behind the GPA, how grades changed over four years, and what the student's school offered.

Should I take AP, honors or regular classes?

There is no right number of AP or honors classes. The right schedule stretches the student most in the subjects tied to their interests, stays manageable alongside activities and rest, and is judged against what the student's own school offers.

Is a B in an AP class better than an A in a regular class?

In most subjects, yes: a B in a harder class usually reads better, because it shows the student chose to stretch. In the subjects tied to the student's intended field, the grade carries more weight, and a C in any advanced class usually means the level was too much at that moment.

Testing

Should I take the SAT or the ACT?

Colleges that use test scores accept both equally, so the right test is the one where the student scores better. Take one full, timed practice test of each, ideally in 10th grade, then prepare for only one.

Is the SAT required for college?

It depends on the college: some require the SAT or ACT, many are test-optional, and a few do not consider scores at all. Our advice is to always take the test, because a score keeps every option open, and a student can still choose not to send it where a college is test-optional.

What is a good SAT score?

A good score is one at or above the middle of the range reported by the colleges on your list. For a sense of scale, College Board's percentiles put 1200 at the 75th percentile and 1360 at the 90th.

How many times should you take the SAT?

Plan on at least two official tests, usually in the spring of 11th grade and again in the summer or early fall. A third makes sense only if practice tests show room to improve and the score still matters for the list; after three, scores usually change little.

How should I study for the SAT?

Start with a full, timed practice test to find where you lose points, then practice those areas in short sessions three or four times a week and review every question you miss. Take a full practice test every three or four weeks; College Board's official practice materials are free.

Essays

How do I choose a college essay topic?

Start from a value you have lived and a moment that changed how you think, not from your most impressive achievement. There is no perfect topic, and you do not need a dramatic story to write a good essay.

How do I start a college essay?

Stop trying to write the first sentence. Write a rough version of the story first, in any order, and write the opening lines last, once you know what the essay is about.

How should a college essay be structured?

A strong essay answers four questions for the reader: where are we, what was hard, what did the student do, and what is different now. Those parts can come in more than one order, and the first two should take up less than half the essay.

What are the most common college essay mistakes?

Picking a topic because it sounds impressive, repeating the activities list, telling a story without saying what it meant, using words the student would never say, and letting too many people edit. Grammar is rarely the problem.

How do I write the "why this college" essay?

Connect specific things at that college, such as a professor's research, a course or a program, to what you have already done and want to do next. If the same paragraph could go to another college by changing the name, it is not specific enough.

Activities

What extracurriculars do colleges look for?

Colleges look for commitment, responsibility and results in a small number of activities. There is no list of preferred activities, and a job or caring for family counts as much as a club or a sport.

How many extracurriculars do you need for college?

No college sets a minimum. The Common App has room for up to ten activities and says applicants do not need to fill all ten; a few activities with real commitment serve a student better than a full list.

Do I need a passion project?

No, but one can show initiative when it grows from an interest the student already has. Start small: choose one real need close to home, make a first version within a month, and grow it only if it keeps your interest.

How do I fill out the Common App activities section?

You can list up to ten activities, each with a 150-character description. Put the most important first, and use each description for facts: what you did, how much, and for whom.

The college list

How do I build a college list?

Start with what the student wants from a college, then check every college against three questions: does it fit, can I get in, and can we afford it. The result is a balanced set of colleges, each one a place the student would be glad to attend.

How many colleges should I apply to?

We recommend about ten to twelve for most students: three to five reach colleges, four to six matches and two to three likely colleges, with at least one that is both likely and affordable. Students applying mostly to colleges that admit a large share of applicants can apply to fewer.

What is the difference between early decision and early action?

Both let a student apply in the fall and hear back sooner. Early action is not binding; early decision is a commitment to attend if admitted, so it only suits a clear first choice the family is sure it can afford.

Cost and financial aid

How much does a private college counselor cost?

Private counselors charge $230 an hour on average, and a typical college package of about two years and 30-plus hours averages $6,304, according to the profession's own survey. The best-known firms charge far more. A school counselor costs nothing, and other AI admissions tools run from free to about $30 a month each; Pursiva costs $49.90 a month.

Do I need a private counselor, or is the school counselor enough?

A school counselor knows your school and is the only one who can send its official documents, but often has hundreds of students. A private counselor offers personal attention at a high price, and an AI counselor built for admissions, like Pursiva, offers a plan and guidance at any hour, working alongside the school counselor.

How does financial aid work, and when should we file the FAFSA?

Financial aid is money that helps a family pay for college: some is free, some is earned and some is borrowed. Nearly all of it starts with the FAFSA, which should be filed in the fall of 12th grade, and some colleges also ask for the CSS Profile.

How much does college really cost?

The sticker price is what a college publishes; the net price is what a family pays after grants and scholarships, and for many families it is far lower. Every college has a net price calculator on its website, so the real cost can be estimated before applying.

Recommendations

Who should write my recommendation letters, and when should I ask?

Ask two teachers who know you well, one who has seen how you think in an academic class and one who has seen what you are like as a person, ideally in the spring of junior year. Choose by how well they know you, not by the grade they gave you, and check each college's rules first.

Using AI

Is using AI on college applications cheating?

Not when it is used for guidance, planning, questions and proofreading. It becomes cheating when AI writes content the student submits as their own, and colleges draw the line in slightly different places, so check each college's policy.

Is it safe to use AI for college applications?

It is safe when the tool is built for that job, and risky when it is a general chatbot with no guardrails. The risks that matter are essays the student did not write, facts that are wrong, and advice from something that does not know the student. Pursiva's Essay coach asks questions and gives feedback, and never writes for the student.

How Pursiva helps

Most of these questions come up one at a time, at different moments over four years. Pursiva keeps them connected. It builds a profile of the student and a plan for each year of high school, and helps find the theme that ties the application together (Pursiva calls it a Core Narrative). That theme then guides the course choices, activities, SAT preparation, essays, recommendations, college list and financial aid. Its Application tracker reminds the family of each task and deadline as it comes up, and it is there whenever a new question appears, for $49.90 a month.

Get answers that fit your student, not just the general case.

$49.90 a month, every module included. Cancel anytime.

Get started