How to Choose a College Essay Topic
Five achievements and a blank page
A senior opens a new document and writes down the five most impressive things she has done. Debate captain. A regional science award. Two hundred hours of volunteering. A summer program at a university. Two years at a weekend job.
She reads the list twice, trying to work out which one a college would most want to hear about. An hour later the page is still blank.
The list is the reason. Every item on it already appears somewhere else in her application, in the activities section or the honors list. Writing 650 words about one of them would repeat what the reader already knows.
What the essay is for
The rest of the application shows what a student has done. The essay is the one place where an admissions reader hears how the student thinks. Yale advises applicants to write about something that matters to them, in their own voice, and says an essay that does not sound like its writer cannot do its job.
A reader who finishes the essay should come away knowing what the student is like and how they think. An achievement cannot show that. A change of mind can.
Step 1: Start with a value
Most students pick a story first and then try to build a personality around it. It works better the other way round. Choose one or two values you have lived, and let them decide what the essay is about.
Three questions help:
- What do I do differently from most people my age, and why?
- What would I refuse to do even if it helped me?
- When did I last change my mind about something that mattered?
Be honest about which values are yours. "Resilience" and "leadership" sound good on paper. The useful ones are those you have paid something for.
Here is the difference in practice, using debate from the list above.
| Starting point | Opening line |
|---|---|
| The achievement | "As debate captain, I led our team to the regional finals, which taught me leadership and public speaking." |
| The value | "I have lost exactly one debate round on purpose. Halfway through, I realized the other side was right, and I could not make myself argue otherwise." |
It is the same student and the same activity. The first line has said everything it has to say. The second has somewhere to go, and a reader wants to know what happened next.
Step 2: Find the before and the after
A topic needs a shift: something you used to think, something that happened, and something you think now. The shift can be small. Deciding you would rather be corrected than be comfortable counts. So does noticing that you avoided a subject for years because you were afraid of being bad at it.
You do not need a hardship. Students often believe a strong essay requires loss or struggle, and so they reach for the most painful thing they can find. A quiet change that is real reads better than a dramatic one that has not been thought through.
To find the shift, fill in three sentences:
- I used to think...
- Then this happened...
- Now I...
Step 3: Collect small moments, then see what links them
Now gather the material. Write down a dozen or so moments you still remember clearly. They do not need to be important. Some places to look:
- An argument you lost and later agreed with
- Something you quit, and the real reason
- A time you were the only one who noticed something
- A rule you broke, or refused to break
- Something you do regularly that nobody asked you to do
Mark the three or four that connect to the value from step 1, and ask what they have in common and what they show about how you have changed.
The answer to that is your topic. It often turns out to be about one of the smaller moments.
Three ways to test a topic
Before writing, check the topic against three questions.
- Could only you write this? If a classmate with the same activities could hand in the same essay, it is still about the activity.
- Is there a change in it? If nothing is different by the end, it is a description.
- Can you say the point in one sentence? If you cannot, the essay will wander.
A topic that passes all three is ready to write, however ordinary it looks.
How Pursiva's Essay coach helps
Pursiva's Essay coach takes a student through these steps by asking the questions, one at a time, and keeping what comes out of them. Ideas are saved as they appear, so a thought from junior year is still there in senior fall. Because Pursiva already holds the student's profile and application theme (Pursiva calls it a Core Narrative), it can point to moments the student has mentioned elsewhere and may have overlooked.
The coach does not write the essay or any part of it. The topic and the words stay the student's own.
The senior from the opening did write about debate in the end. Her essay is about the one round she chose to lose and what it taught her about changing her mind, which appears nowhere else in her application.
Sources
Find the essay only your student can write.
$49.90 a month, every module included. Cancel anytime.
Get started